New musicals take time to develop, and Silver Tongue, based loosely on Robert Louis Stevenson’s classic pirate tale, Treasure Island, while benefitting from six years in development and delivering a rousing night, still has a way to go.
While Silver Tongue delivers the musical numbers and laughs in spades, it is let down somewhat by an undercooked script that does not quite engage in the story telling department and misses the high stakes, including not delivering on its promise of a queer take on the original story.
In this retelling from the pens of Jacob Parker and Miranda Middleton, the story opens in a port bar, with musicians beating out a slow shanty on kegs which segue into Down at the Benbow as the sailors scull rum and tell tall tales.
We are introduced to the young Jim (Marty Alix), and his innkeeper father (Jack Green), who is quickly distracted by the pirate queen Silver Tongue (Billie Palin), Dick (Natalie Abbott), and grog.
Jim laments his future at the pub, and dreaming of a life elsewhere, sings the beautiful Write My Story. It quickly transpires that Jim has a treasure map, and it is up to Silver Tongue to acquire this, even if it means leading Jim into the life of a pirate on the high seas.
Enter Jack Green again, this time playing the Squire, who by defrauding his brother, has managed to acquire a ship, along with an inflated sense of ability and pronunciation.
Setting sail, and with no sailing knowledge, management or map reading skills, he must hold the crew together, while they must keep their identities to themselves.
A great dramatic moment is when the crew enters a storm that threatens the ship, which brings out the sea dog skills of Silver Tongue and Hands (Tana Laga’aia), while underscored by the instrumental The Storm.
Guided by the most basic of directions, the crew eventually find land, which is celebrated by the song Land Ho! and the shenanigans and truth telling really begin.
Director Richard Carroll has a firm hand across the action, and it does get boisterous at times, thanks to fight director Ryan McDonald, while giving us distinction between the tension of the action and the beats of personal reflection. However, not all of the jokes land, and too much time is spent of this expectation.
Dance Captain, Shannen Alyce Quan, also Livesey in the cast, has done a great job with Chiara Assetta’s choreography, while allowing Palin’s Silver Tongue to show off her natural physical strength.
Where Silver Tongue as a production shines is in its music, which swings from robust sea shanties to often tender folk tunes, ending in the coming together moment of Find Your Way Home.
With its musical strength, Silver Tongue is a great platform for cellist Asli Ibrahim, Jarrad Payne (percussion) and fiddler and composer Alec Steedman to shine, under the musical direction of Victoria Falconer, who also plays Peg.
Musically, Tana Laga’aia is in danger of being accused of being a show-off as he shows such great musical ability and voice across such a large number of instruments.
Hailley Hunt’s two main sets of the pub and the ship share neutral tones that are ingenious in the way that with few props give a sense of time and place to the production.
Round this out with Sam Hernandez’s costumes, Ryan McDonald’s lighting and Daniel Herten’s sound design, and Silver Tongue is one classy production, with a strong cast that delivers a great night of entertainment from a home grown musical that has the legs for another run.
Silver Tongue
Hayes Theatre Co, 19 Greenknowe Avenue, Elizabeth Bay (Sydney)
Performance: Wednesday 18 November 2026
Season continues to 19 December 2026
Information and Bookings: www.hayestheatre.com.au
Images: Billie Palin and Lawrence Hawkins in Silver Tongue – photo by John McRae | Billie Palin in Silver Tongue – photo by John McRae | The Company of Silver Tongue – photo by John McRae | Alec Steedman and Victoria Falconer in Silver Tongue – photo by John McRae | Tana Laga’aia in Silver Tongue – photo by John McRae
Review: John Moyle
