Tristan and Isolde

BK Opera Tristan and Isolde James Egglestone and Lee Abrahmsen photo by Ben FonFor 10 years BK Opera has been shaking up Melbourne’s fringe opera scene, reimagining works in intimate settings and punching above its weight with theatrically inventive productions.

Perhaps Melbourne’s established love affair with Wagner prompted the company to tackle the composer’s monumental Tristan and Isolde, a sprawling, transcendental love story that might paradoxically be among his most rewarding works to explore intimately. The ambition is considerable. 

Wagner explores the transcendent possibilities of all-consuming passion, whereas artistic director Kate Millett frames the lovers’ relationship as destructive obsession. Her synopsis describes their passion as an “all-annihilating limerence that feeds on itself”, with death the only possible fulfilment. In this reading, the potion becomes almost incidental – whether love or death is intended, the lovers are driven towards the same outcome.

That premise is most evident after the death potion is taken, when the couple bypass any suggestion of romantic connection and plunge into carnal desire. Isolde appears to take the lead, at one point guiding Tristan up a flight of steps, yet her expression suggests anguish rather than pleasure. The encounter seems almost punitive, a response to Tristan’s earlier deceit rather than an expression of mutual desire.

A more tender dimension emerges as Tristan lies dying and Isolde finally offers comfort. Her subsequent Liebestod brings a striking change of demeanour. Statuesque and resolute, she delivers a moment in which voice and music seem to meld, briefly aligning the emotional and theatrical worlds. Here, Millett’s vision of death as completion finds its most persuasive expression.

BK Opera Tristan and Isolde Belinda Dalton and Lee Abrahmsen photo by Ben FonThe visual world is central to Millett’s approach. Ishan Vivekanantham’s set establishes a nautical setting through a raised rectangular platform occupying almost half the hall, surrounding a central canvas, tent-like structure. Ship-like, balustraded steps lead to the curtained proscenium, while raked seating at one end and rows of chairs along either side complete the arrangement. 

It’s an impressive construction. The configuration gives Millett scope to create isolated focal points and multiple areas of activity, while retaining depth and proximity to the audience.

After the potion is taken, the canvas peels back to reveal a bed of flowers, apparently alluding to the blossoming of love Brangäne’s potion is intended to inspire. As the lovers’ passions intensify, however, the area collapses, perhaps suggesting a relationship destined to unravel.

Reflecting the work’s contrasts, Oliver Hall’s costumes range from understated to boldly caricatured as the flowerbed reveal brings an unexpected turn – crepe-paper creations transform Isolde into what could have been a goldfish and Tristan into a black counterpart – costumes that seem to offer little in the way of practicality. Whether this signals an imagined realm or a divergent world into which Isolde has entered is difficult to determine.

Gabriel Bethune’s lighting moves through successive moods, but could make more dramatic use of downlighting to isolate key moments and deepen the sense of darkness.

BK Opera Tristan and Isolde Lee Abrahmsen photo by Ben FonMusically, the three-hour version, with a short interval, preserves much of the narrative arc. The two-piano arrangement, however, often struggles to colour and sustain the drama, despite conductor Kelly Lovelady establishing a well-judged range of tempi. Delicate, exposed passages, with Wagner’s sustained chords given room to resonate, prove the most compelling. 

Too often, however, voices and accompaniment seem at odds, disrupting the theatrical rhythm. The arrangement’s limitations are compounded by an uncomfortable balance between the voices and the pianos, played by Konrad Olszewski and Shauna Beesley.

The cast brings considerable professional experience, including familiarity with Wagner, although the results are uneven. Soprano Lee Abrahmsen conveys Isolde’s humiliation at being taken to marry King Marke, and her determination, through expressive physicality and vocal richness.

In her upper range, the highest notes often broke into a harshness as the voice exploded into overextended fortissimo, although she is affectingly powerful in the ecstatic release of the Liebestod.

BK Opera Tristan und Isolde James Egglestone photo by Ben FonJames Egglestone provides a measured counterpoint as Tristan, an assured and sincere figure conveyed through his warm, vibrant tenor, and elicits well-earned sympathy as Tristan struggles with the conflict between desire and duty, and later with the agony of separation from Isolde. 

Together, the chemistry between them is often more convincing in the tension when they are physically separated than in their graphic but unconvincingly mechanical lovemaking.

It had been announced that heldenbaritone Warwick Fyfe was unwell, but his arrival as Marke as the lovers are discovered immediately adds dramatic tension. Brooding and authoritative, with a hint of self-consciousness, he brings a broad, expressive vocal style to Marke’s confrontation with the lovers, and his more introspective presence in the final scene adds depth to Isolde’s ecstatic Liebestod.

BK Opera Tristan and Isolde Warwick Fyfe photo by Ben FonSoprano Belinda Dalton builds her performance intelligently as Brangäne, with increasingly lush vocalism. An astute observer, she also gives voice to what Isolde cannot express.

As Kurwenal, Henry Shaw combines a toasty, resonant bass-baritone with neatly calibrated amplitude and acting responsive to the interplay of music and drama. His tender attention to Tristan’s wounds makes his loyalty particularly affecting. 

Daniel Sziesong Todd’s ardent, impatient Melot has a strong stage presence, while James Penn’s clarion tenor and the off-stage ensemble of sailors, knights and esquires add dramatic texture.

There are practical distractions that also affect the audience experience. Large surtitles projected onto the stage curtain are frequently cut off by its folds. From my seat at one side of the auditorium on opening night, Brangäne blocked my view of Isolde’s opening exchange with her.

BK Opera Tristan and Isolde Belinda Dalton photo by Ben FonThankfully, I caught the moment Isolde raises a dagger towards the audience and declares “Vengeance!” in a gesture that resonates with the production’s affecting conclusion, as she stands victorious, having achieved the outcome she has pursued from the beginning.

Millett’s concept is not always clearly realised, but gives Isolde agency in shaping her own fate and makes persuasive her premise that the distinction between the substituted love potion and the intended death potion barely matters. 

Beyond this production, the performance demonstrates that Tristan and Isolde can make a compelling case in scaled-down form, although a more detailed musical arrangement – even with two pianos – would help realise its full dramatic potential.


Tristan and Isolde
Northcote Town Hall Arts Centre, 189 High Street, Northcote
Performances: 29 & 31 October 2026
Bookings: www.arts.darebin.vic.gov.au

For more information, visit: www.bkopera.com.au for details.

Images: James Egglestone and Lee Abrahmsen – photo by Ben Fon | Belinda Dalton and Lee Abrahmsen – photo by Ben Fon | Lee Abrahmsen – photo by Ben Fon | James Egglestone – photo by Ben Fon | Warwick Fyfe – photo by Ben Fon | Belinda Dalton – photo by Ben Fon

Review: Paul Selar